An Octagon-Shaped Lake House 50 Miles From Manhattan Finds a Buyer at $1.7 Million

A lakefront home in Truesdale Lake, South Salem, New York has sold for $1.7 million (~€1.46M). The property went into foreclosure in 2024 and was listed for sale by the lender. It is located on Truesdale Lake, a private residential lake community developed in the 1920s. 

Originally built in 1980, the house spans approximately 3,700 square feet / 344 m² and is configured with two bedrooms and four bathrooms. The structure is notably designed in an octagonal shape, a layout that distinguishes it from more conventional homes in the area. Features include a bar, wine cellar, exposed wood beams, vaulted ceilings, large windows facing the lake, and a separate garage.

Outdoor elements include a wraparound deck with BBQ, landscaped grounds, dock, and direct water access and the property sits on roughly half an acre / 0.2 hectares along Truesdale Lake.

Truesdale Lake is an established residential enclave in northern Westchester County, located about an hour from New York City and known for its low-density setting and private water access. Homes in the area are typically used as primary or weekend residences, with value tied to lake frontage and proximity to the city.

All photos belong to the listing agency.